- Sympathetic Ophthalmia
- Penetrating ocular trauma or surgery
- VKH Disease
- Autoimmune — no trauma history
Sympathetic ophthalmia
Key Points
- •Sympathetic ophthalmia is clinically and histopathologically identical to VKH disease — the sole distinguishing criterion is history of penetrating ocular trauma or surgery
- •Risk after penetrating ocular trauma: 0.2–0.5%; after intraocular surgery: 0.01–0.03%. 80% of cases occur within 3 months of injury; 90% within 1 year
- •Dalen-Fuchs nodules (epithelioid cells between Bruch's membrane and RPE) are characteristic (present in ~25–35% of cases; also seen in VKH); the choriocapillaris is classically spared on histopathology
- •Enucleation of the exciting eye AFTER sympathetic ophthalmia develops does NOT alter the course of disease — the autoimmune response is already systemic
- •Early aggressive immunosuppression with high-dose steroids + IMT within 2 weeks is essential; 60–70% of sympathizing eyes maintain ≥6/12 with early treatment
A rare, bilateral, diffuse, granulomatous panuveitis that occurs following penetrating trauma or surgical violation of one eye (the exciting eye), subsequently affecting the fellow non-injured eye (the sympathizing eye). It is a T-cell mediated autoimmune response against uveal/retinal melanocyte antigens exposed by the initial injury — clinically and histopathologically identical to VKH disease, distinguished only by the history of penetrating trauma or surgery.
Incidence: approximately 0.03 per 100,000 per year. Risk after penetrating ocular trauma: 0.2–0.5%. Risk after intraocular surgery: 0.01–0.03% (much lower than trauma). Risk is highest after vitreoretinal surgery, particularly with uveal prolapse or multiple procedures. No racial predilection (unlike VKH). Males slightly more affected due to higher trauma incidence. Can occur at any age; mean onset 25–45 years. Onset timing: 80% occur within 3 months of injury; 90% within 1 year. Earliest reported onset: 5 days post-injury. Can occur years to decades after the inciting event (Nussenblatt & Whitcup, Uveitis, 4th Ed).
Penetrating ocular trauma (most common cause, ~60–70% of cases) — especially injuries involving uveal tissue prolapse or incarceration in the wound.
Intraocular surgery (~30%): especially vitreoretinal surgery, secondary IOL procedures, cyclodestructive procedures (cyclocryotherapy, transscleral diode laser).
Mechanism: Disruption of ocular immune privilege exposes sequestered melanocyte-associated antigens — tyrosinase, TRP1, TRP2, S-antigen, IRBP (interphotoreceptor retinoid-binding protein) — to the systemic immune system. The immune system, never having been tolerized to these antigens, mounts a T-cell mediated autoimmune attack targeting melanocytes in both eyes.
- Penetrating injury disrupts the blood-ocular barrier and allows sequestered uveal/retinal antigens to reach regional (cervical/preauricular) lymph nodes.
- Antigen-presenting cells (dendritic cells, macrophages) process melanocyte-derived peptides and present them to naive CD4+ T cells via MHC class II molecules (HLA-DR4, HLA-DRB1*0405).
- Sensitized Th1 and Th17 cells recognize melanocyte antigens systemically, and traffic to the uveal tracts of BOTH eyes via hematogenous spread.
- Granulomatous choroidal inflammation develops: diffuse lymphocytic and epithelioid cell infiltration of the choroid.
- Dalen-Fuchs nodules (collections of epithelioid cells and RPE cells between Bruch's membrane and the RPE) form in the mid-periphery — characteristic finding (present in ~25–35% of cases; also seen in VKH).
- The choriocapillaris is classically spared (unlike many other choroiditides) — key histopathological feature (focal involvement may occur in severe cases).
- Retinal involvement is minimal compared to choroidal involvement (retinal sparing is characteristic).
Clinical classification:
- Anterior form — predominantly granulomatous anterior uveitis (less common presentation)
- Posterior/diffuse form — diffuse choroiditis with exudative retinal detachments (classic presentation)
- Mixed/panuveitis form — combined anterior and posterior involvement (most typical in practice)
Histopathological classification:
- Non-necrotizing diffuse granulomatous uveal inflammation
- Dalen-Fuchs nodules present (between RPE and Bruch's membrane)
- Choriocapillaris spared (key feature)
- Retinal sparing (inflammation confined to uveal tract)
Timing of onset after inciting event:
- Early: <2 weeks (rare, <1% of cases)
- Typical: 2 weeks to 3 months
- Classic window: within 3 months (80% of cases); within 1 year (90%)
- Late: >1 year (up to decades later)
- Penetrating ocular trauma with uveal prolapse or incarceration in wound (greatest risk)
- Retained intraocular foreign body (IOFB)
- Multiple intraocular surgeries
- Vitreoretinal surgery (higher risk than anterior segment surgery)
- Cyclodestructive procedures (cyclocryotherapy, transscleral diode laser)
- Delayed primary repair (>24 hours post-trauma)
- Wound dehiscence with uveal incarceration
- HLA-DR4 and HLA-DRB1*0405 association (same genetic predisposition as VKH)
- No association with blunt (non-penetrating) trauma
- Enucleation performed within 10–14 days of injury was historically considered protective — now debated
Exciting eye: history of penetrating trauma or surgery; may show chronic inflammation, phthisis bulbi, or active granulomatous uveitis.
Sympathizing eye (fellow eye) — key diagnostic findings:
- Bilateral granulomatous anterior uveitis: mutton-fat KPs, posterior synechiae
- Anterior chamber cells and flare
- Iris thickening with Koeppe and Busacca nodules
- Moderate to severe vitritis
- Dalen-Fuchs nodules: small, round, yellow-white lesions at RPE level (mid-periphery > posterior pole) — characteristic (present in ~25–35% of cases)
- Multifocal serous/exudative retinal detachments (bilateral)
- Choroidal thickening (diffuse)
- Optic disc edema and hyperemia
- Sunset-glow fundus (chronic phase — diffuse choroidal depigmentation similar to VKH)
- Peripapillary atrophy
Systemic findings (uncommon — unlike VKH):
- Vitiligo, poliosis, alopecia (rarely; same integumentary features as VKH)
- Meningismus and CSF lymphocytic pleocytosis (rarely)
- Sensorineural hearing loss / dysacusis (rarely)
Ophthalmic imaging:
- FFA: multiple pinpoint hyperfluorescent leakage points at RPE level (similar to VKH), disc leakage, pooling in serous RDs — 'starry sky' pattern
- ICGA: multiple hypofluorescent dark dots (choroidal granulomata), more sensitive than FFA for detecting choroidal lesions
- OCT/EDI-OCT: subretinal fluid, choroidal thickening (>400 µm acutely), RPE undulations, Dalen-Fuchs nodule imaging
- B-scan ultrasonography: diffuse choroidal thickening, serous RD, no posterior scleral T-sign (unlike posterior scleritis)
Laboratory (to exclude mimics):
- No specific serological marker for sympathetic ophthalmia
- HLA-DR4 typing (supportive)
- Rule out: FTA-ABS/RPR (syphilis), QuantiFERON-TB Gold (ocular TB), ACE/lysozyme (sarcoidosis), chest X-ray
Histopathology (of enucleated exciting eye — gold standard for definitive diagnosis):
- Diffuse non-necrotizing granulomatous choroidal inflammation
- Dalen-Fuchs nodules between RPE and Bruch's membrane
- Epithelioid cells, multinucleated giant cells, lymphocytes
- Choriocapillaris spared
- No retinal necrosis
Clinical diagnosis is based on: history of penetrating trauma/surgery + bilateral granulomatous panuveitis in the sympathizing eye.
- Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada disease — identical clinical and histopathological features; distinguished ONLY by the absence of prior penetrating trauma or surgery in VKH
- Sarcoid panuveitis — bilateral granulomatous panuveitis, but with systemic features (hilar lymphadenopathy, skin lesions, elevated ACE) and no trauma history; non-caseating granulomata on biopsy
- Phacoanaphylactic uveitis — granulomatous inflammation centered around lens material; zonal pattern on histology; follows lens disruption
- Syphilitic panuveitis — bilateral granulomatous uveitis; positive serology (FTA-ABS, VDRL/RPR)
- Tubercular panuveitis — bilateral choroidal granulomata; positive QuantiFERON-TB/Mantoux; caseating granulomata on biopsy
- Endogenous endophthalmitis — bilateral in rare disseminated cases; associated systemic sepsis/immunosuppression; positive cultures
- Cataract (most common, ~50–70%, from chronic inflammation and steroid use)
- Secondary glaucoma (~25–40%, from synechial angle closure, pupillary block, or steroid-induced IOP elevation)
- CME (~20–30%, significant cause of visual morbidity)
- Subretinal fibrosis (~10–20%)
- Choroidal neovascularization (~10%, sub-foveal CNV carries worst visual prognosis)
- Exudative retinal detachment (acute phase)
- Optic atrophy (from chronic disc inflammation)
- Band keratopathy (calcium deposition from chronic inflammation)
- Phthisis bulbi of exciting eye
- Chronic hypotony
- Sunset-glow fundus (chronic depigmentation, similar to VKH)
- Seclusion/occlusion of pupil
Prevention (primary):
- Primary wound repair within 24 hours of penetrating injury with repositioning of prolapsed uveal tissue
- Enucleation of a traumatized blind (NLP) eye within 10–14 days of injury was historically recommended — now increasingly debated; modern aggressive immunosuppression has reduced urgency. After sympathetic ophthalmia develops, enucleation of the exciting eye does NOT improve outcomes in the sympathizing eye.
Medical management — early aggressive immunosuppression:
- IV methylprednisolone 1 g/day x 3 days (pulse therapy) for acute/severe disease
- Oral prednisolone 1–1.5 mg/kg/day — very slow taper over minimum 12–18 months
- Maintain prednisolone ≥10 mg/day for at least 3–6 months; rapid taper causes high recurrence rate
Steroid-sparing IMT (recommended early, within 2 weeks of diagnosis):
- Cyclosporine 3–5 mg/kg/day (often first-line IMT)
- Mycophenolate mofetil 1–2 g/day
- Azathioprine 2–3 mg/kg/day
- Methotrexate 15–25 mg/week (with folic acid supplementation)
Biologics (refractory disease):
- Adalimumab 40 mg SC every 2 weeks (VISUAL I/II trials — established for non-infectious uveitis)
- Infliximab 5 mg/kg IV at 0, 2, 6 weeks then every 8 weeks
Local therapy:
- Topical prednisolone acetate 1% for anterior segment
- Atropine 1% TID (cycloplegia, synechiae prevention)
- Intravitreal anti-VEGF (ranibizumab, bevacizumab) for CNV
- Intravitreal dexamethasone implant (Ozurdex 0.7 mg) for refractory CME
With modern aggressive immunosuppression, visual prognosis has significantly improved. Approximately 60–70% of sympathizing eyes maintain VA ≥6/12 with early treatment. Exciting eye prognosis depends on severity of initial trauma.
Poor prognostic factors: delayed diagnosis, inadequate immunosuppression, recurrent inflammation, CME, subretinal fibrosis, subfoveal CNV, sunset-glow fundus (indicates chronicity).
Recurrence rate: 40–60% with steroid monotherapy; significantly reduced with early IMT. Treatment is often required for years to decades; many patients need lifelong low-dose IMT.
The condition can recur even years after apparent quiescence — long-term ophthalmological follow-up is mandatory.
Clinical Pearls
Oral-exam questions
- What is the only clinical feature that distinguishes sympathetic ophthalmia from VKH disease? — History of penetrating ocular trauma or surgery (the exciting eye). Histopathologically, both are indistinguishable (Nussenblatt & Whitcup, Uveitis, 4th Ed).
- What is the minimum latent period before sympathetic ophthalmia can develop? — 5 days post-injury. Onset within the first 2 weeks is rare (<1% of cases); 80% occur within 3 months; 90% within 1 year.
- Name the characteristic histopathological finding — Dalen-Fuchs nodules: collections of epithelioid cells between Bruch's membrane and the RPE, in the mid-periphery (present in ~25–35% of cases). The choriocapillaris is classically spared — another key histopathological feature.
- Does enucleating the exciting eye after sympathetic ophthalmia develops help the sympathizing eye? — No. Once the autoimmune response is systemic, removing the exciting eye does NOT alter the course of disease in the sympathizing eye. Enucleation is now rarely performed and is limited to a blind, painful exciting eye.
- Which IGRA test is most useful to exclude TB as a mimic? — QuantiFERON-TB Gold Plus — preferred over Mantoux (TST) in BCG-vaccinated populations due to higher specificity for M. tuberculosis-specific antigens (ESAT-6, CFP-10).
- What trial evidence supports biologic use in sympathetic ophthalmia? — VISUAL I and VISUAL II trials established adalimumab (anti-TNF-α) for non-infectious intermediate, posterior, and panuveitis. VISUAL I: HR 0.50 (50% reduction in treatment failure risk; median time to failure 24 weeks vs 13 weeks). VISUAL II: treatment failure 39% adalimumab vs 55% placebo during steroid taper.
- What is the minimum duration of immunosuppression in sympathetic ophthalmia? — Prednisolone taper over minimum 12–18 months; maintain ≥10 mg/day for at least 3–6 months. Rapid taper is the most common cause of recurrence (40–60% recurrence with steroid monotherapy).
- What is the pathological hallmark of sympathetic ophthalmia? — Diffuse granulomatous inflammation of the entire uveal tract with non-caseating granulomas, epithelioid cells, and Dalen-Fuchs nodules (collections of epithelioid cells between Bruch's membrane and RPE). The choriocapillaris is typically spared (unlike VKH where it may be involved). The absence of choriocapillaris involvement is a classic histopathological differentiator.
- Can sympathetic ophthalmia occur after vitreoretinal surgery? — Yes, rarely. SO has been reported after PPV, scleral buckling, and even after repeated intravitreal injections (extremely rare). Any procedure that violates the uveal tissue theoretically carries risk. The incidence after PPV is estimated at 0.01–0.03%. Patients should be counseled about this remote risk.
Mnemonics
PETS
DALES
Comparison Tables
| Feature | Sympathetic Ophthalmia | VKH Disease |
|---|---|---|
| Etiology | Penetrating ocular trauma or surgery | Autoimmune — no trauma history |
| Exciting eye | Present (injured eye) | Not applicable |
| Racial predilection | None | Asians, Hispanics, South Asians, Native Americans |
| Histopathology | Non-necrotizing granulomatous choroiditis; Dalen-Fuchs nodules; choriocapillaris spared | IDENTICAL — indistinguishable on biopsy |
| Integumentary changes | Rare (vitiligo, poliosis uncommon) | Common — vitiligo, poliosis, alopecia in convalescent phase |
| Neurological features | Very rare | Meningismus, CSF pleocytosis in ~80% within first 2 weeks |
| Sugiura sign | Not described | Characteristic (perilimbal vitiligo) |
| HLA association | HLA-DR4, DRB1*0405 | HLA-DRB1*0405 (stronger; OR ~10) |
| Treatment | Aggressive steroids + IMT | Aggressive steroids + IMT (identical) |
- Sympathetic Ophthalmia
- Present (injured eye)
- VKH Disease
- Not applicable
- Sympathetic Ophthalmia
- None
- VKH Disease
- Asians, Hispanics, South Asians, Native Americans
- Sympathetic Ophthalmia
- Non-necrotizing granulomatous choroiditis; Dalen-Fuchs nodules; choriocapillaris spared
- VKH Disease
- IDENTICAL — indistinguishable on biopsy
- Sympathetic Ophthalmia
- Rare (vitiligo, poliosis uncommon)
- VKH Disease
- Common — vitiligo, poliosis, alopecia in convalescent phase
- Sympathetic Ophthalmia
- Very rare
- VKH Disease
- Meningismus, CSF pleocytosis in ~80% within first 2 weeks
- Sympathetic Ophthalmia
- Not described
- VKH Disease
- Characteristic (perilimbal vitiligo)
- Sympathetic Ophthalmia
- HLA-DR4, DRB1*0405
- VKH Disease
- HLA-DRB1*0405 (stronger; OR ~10)
- Sympathetic Ophthalmia
- Aggressive steroids + IMT
- VKH Disease
- Aggressive steroids + IMT (identical)
| Agent | Dose | Key Monitoring | Advantages | Main Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cyclosporine | 3–5 mg/kg/day PO | Renal function, BP, trough levels | Rapid onset, effective | Nephrotoxicity, hypertension |
| Mycophenolate mofetil | 1–2 g/day PO | CBC, LFT | Well-tolerated, evidence from FIRST trial | GI side effects, teratogen |
| Azathioprine | 2–3 mg/kg/day PO | CBC (check TPMT first), LFT | Long safety record | Myelosuppression, lymphoma risk |
| Methotrexate | 15–25 mg/week PO/SC | CBC, LFT, renal function | Inexpensive, dual uveitis/arthritis use | Hepatotoxicity, pneumonitis |
| Adalimumab | 40 mg SC q2w | Latent TB screen, CBC | Biologic, strong evidence (VISUAL I/II) | Infection, TB reactivation, cost |
- Dose
- 3–5 mg/kg/day PO
- Key Monitoring
- Renal function, BP, trough levels
- Advantages
- Rapid onset, effective
- Main Risk
- Nephrotoxicity, hypertension
- Dose
- 1–2 g/day PO
- Key Monitoring
- CBC, LFT
- Advantages
- Well-tolerated, evidence from FIRST trial
- Main Risk
- GI side effects, teratogen
- Dose
- 2–3 mg/kg/day PO
- Key Monitoring
- CBC (check TPMT first), LFT
- Advantages
- Long safety record
- Main Risk
- Myelosuppression, lymphoma risk
- Dose
- 15–25 mg/week PO/SC
- Key Monitoring
- CBC, LFT, renal function
- Advantages
- Inexpensive, dual uveitis/arthritis use
- Main Risk
- Hepatotoxicity, pneumonitis
- Dose
- 40 mg SC q2w
- Key Monitoring
- Latent TB screen, CBC
- Advantages
- Biologic, strong evidence (VISUAL I/II)
- Main Risk
- Infection, TB reactivation, cost
| Event | Timeframe | Clinical Implication |
|---|---|---|
| Earliest possible onset | ≥5 days post-injury | Below 5 days — reconsider diagnosis |
| Highest-risk period (80% of cases) | Within 3 months of injury | Monitor sympathizing eye closely; 90% present within 1 year |
| Historical enucleation window | Within 10–14 days of injury | Historically protective; now debated with modern IMT |
| IMT initiation target | Within 2 weeks of diagnosis | Early IMT significantly improves visual outcomes |
| Minimum steroid taper duration | 12–18 months | Rapid taper = high recurrence |
| Recurrence window | Years to decades | Long-term follow-up mandatory |
- Timeframe
- ≥5 days post-injury
- Clinical Implication
- Below 5 days — reconsider diagnosis
- Timeframe
- Within 3 months of injury
- Clinical Implication
- Monitor sympathizing eye closely; 90% present within 1 year
- Timeframe
- Within 10–14 days of injury
- Clinical Implication
- Historically protective; now debated with modern IMT
- Timeframe
- Within 2 weeks of diagnosis
- Clinical Implication
- Early IMT significantly improves visual outcomes
- Timeframe
- 12–18 months
- Clinical Implication
- Rapid taper = high recurrence
- Timeframe
- Years to decades
- Clinical Implication
- Long-term follow-up mandatory
| Modality | Acute Phase Findings | Chronic Phase Findings | Clinical Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| FFA | Pinpoint RPE leaks, 'starry sky', disc leakage, pooling in serous RD | Window defects, RPE atrophy, CNV leakage | Diagnosis, monitoring exudation |
| ICGA | Multiple hypofluorescent dark dots (granulomata), fuzzy choroidal vessels | Persistent dark dots in treated choroidal scars | Most sensitive for choroidal granulomata |
| OCT/EDI-OCT | Subretinal fluid, choroidal thickening (>400 µm), RPE undulations | Choroidal thinning, subretinal fibrosis, CME | Quantitative monitoring of treatment response |
| B-scan USG | Diffuse choroidal thickening, serous RD | Choroidal thickening (resolves with treatment) | Useful when media hazy |
- Acute Phase Findings
- Pinpoint RPE leaks, 'starry sky', disc leakage, pooling in serous RD
- Chronic Phase Findings
- Window defects, RPE atrophy, CNV leakage
- Clinical Use
- Diagnosis, monitoring exudation
- Acute Phase Findings
- Multiple hypofluorescent dark dots (granulomata), fuzzy choroidal vessels
- Chronic Phase Findings
- Persistent dark dots in treated choroidal scars
- Clinical Use
- Most sensitive for choroidal granulomata
- Acute Phase Findings
- Subretinal fluid, choroidal thickening (>400 µm), RPE undulations
- Chronic Phase Findings
- Choroidal thinning, subretinal fibrosis, CME
- Clinical Use
- Quantitative monitoring of treatment response
- Acute Phase Findings
- Diffuse choroidal thickening, serous RD
- Chronic Phase Findings
- Choroidal thickening (resolves with treatment)
- Clinical Use
- Useful when media hazy
Self-Assessment (5)
A 28-year-old man presents with bilateral granulomatous uveitis, exudative retinal detachments, and Dalen-Fuchs nodules 4 months after a penetrating corneal injury to his left eye. What is the diagnosis?
Histopathological examination of an enucleated exciting eye shows non-necrotizing granulomatous choroidal inflammation with epithelioid cells between Bruch's membrane and the RPE, with the choriocapillaris spared. What is the characteristic finding described?
A 35-year-old woman develops sympathetic ophthalmia 6 months after vitreoretinal surgery. Her exciting eye is blind (NLP) and painful. Which of the following statements about enucleation of the exciting eye is correct?
What is the minimum latent period classically described between penetrating ocular injury and the onset of sympathetic ophthalmia?
Which clinical trial established the evidence base for adalimumab use in patients with active non-infectious uveitis, including sympathetic ophthalmia?
References
- Nussenblatt RB, Whitcup SM. Uveitis: Fundamentals and Clinical Practice, 4th Edition. Elsevier; 2010.
- Greco A, Fusconi M, Gallo A, et al. Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada syndrome. Autoimmun Rev. 2013;12(11):1033-1038.
- Jaffe GJ, Dick AD, Brezin AP, et al. Adalimumab in patients with active noninfectious uveitis (VISUAL I). N Engl J Med. 2016;375(10):932-943.
- Nguyen QD, Merrill PT, Jaffe GJ, et al. Adalimumab for prevention of uveitic flare in patients with inactive non-infectious uveitis controlled by corticosteroids (VISUAL II). Lancet. 2016;388(10050):1183-1192.
- Chan CC, Roberge FG, Whitcup SM, Nussenblatt RB. 32 cases of sympathetic ophthalmia. A retrospective study at the National Eye Institute, Bethesda, Md., from 1982 to 1992. Arch Ophthalmol. 1995;113(5):597-600.
- Cunningham ET Jr. Sympathetic ophthalmia. In: Yanoff M, Duker JS, eds. Ophthalmology, 5th Edition. Elsevier; 2019.
- Standardization of Uveitis Nomenclature (SUN) Working Group. Standardization of uveitis nomenclature for reporting clinical data. Results of the First International Workshop. Am J Ophthalmol. 2005;140(3):509-516.
- AAO Preferred Practice Pattern: Uveitis — Management of Non-Infectious Uveitis. American Academy of Ophthalmology, latest edition.
Related Content
Topic complete
Continue to another topic when you are ready.